This history lesson is a little long. If you want, skip down to the longish quote from Fadiman and start there. For those who are game, here’s a quick run through:
The Geneva Accords of 1954 recognized three states in what had previously been French Indochina. These were Cambodia, Laos, and Vietnam (temporarily divided into North and South, intended to be unified later). Laos was supposed to be neutral and, according to the Geneva Conference of 1961, the US, Soviet Union, North and South Vietnam and several other nations agreed to respect that neutrality, agreeing not to send in “any foreign troops or military personnel.”
Except that the we didn’t really want to respect that neutrality (to be fair, no one else did either). The US had been providing covert support to the anti-communist Royal Lao army since 1955 as they struggled against the Communist Pathet Lao for control of the country. But we wanted to step up our game, because Eisenhower, and then Kennedy after him, believed that if Laos fell to Communism, Thailand, Cambodia, South Vietnam, and Burma would be right behind.
And so, a cadre of CIA advisors were sent in to train a secret guerrilla army of Hmong soldiers to fight the war by proxy. Continued under Johnson and then Nixon, this secret army eventually grew to more than 30,000 strong.
There is a lot about this story that is complicated. Some call the Hmong mercenaries. And, for the most part, they were paid. But it was $3 a month compared to the $200-$300 per month an army private in Vietnam received. Not all of them signed up voluntarily as many villages had solider “quotas” they had to fill to avoid punishment. And displaced from their farmland by the bombing in Northern Laos, few had real alternatives.
For a more detailed (and better!) summary, Anne Fadiman gives a stellar primer on the subject, as I alluded to here. The story actually first broke in 1987 when a British investigative journalist wrote The Ravens: The Men Who Flew in America’s Secret War in Laos (which I haven’t read, but is supposed to be good).
Regardless, in 1973, the US signed the Paris Agreements, pledging to remove all forces from Vietnam. In 1975, the Communist Lao People’s Democratic Republic took control, the party’s newspaper announcing that the Hmong “must be exterminated down to the root of the tribe.”
American planes airlifted between 1,000-3,000 high-ranking army officers and their families to Thailand, leaving tens of thousands of vulnerable Hmong behind. After the last American place took off, many of those remaining began the long and dangerous journey to Thailand, where they would spend years, even decades, in refugee camps along the border. Others tried to stay and survive the Vietnamese persecution. Some were successful, others ended up following the first wave to the Thai border.
About 10,000 Hmong eventually emigrated to France, Canada, Australia, Argentina, or elsewhere. But most, because of what the Hmong refer to as “The Promise,” set their sights on the US. For this, I’ll just quote directly from Fadiman as she says it better than I could:
Every Hmong has a version of what is commonly called “The Promise”: a written or oral contract, made by CIA personnel in Laos, that if they fought for the Americans, the Americans would aid them if the Pathet Lao won the war. After risking their lives to rescue downed American pilots, seeing their villages flattened by incidental American bombs, and being forced to flee their country because they had supported the “American War,” the Hmong expected a hero’s welcome here. According to many of them, the first betrayal came when the American airlifts rescued only the officers from Long Tieng, leaving nearly everyone else behind. The second betrayal came in the Thai camps when the Hmong who wanted to come to the United States were not all automatically admitted. The third betrayal came when they arrived here and found they were ineligible for veterans’ benefits. The fourth betrayal came when Americans condemned them for what the Hmong call “eating welfare.”
And so. We ended up with a sizable Hmong community in the United States. And, well, no one really knows (or remembers) that that’s why they’re here. Because we asked them to fight a war for us so that we could avoid international condemnation for violating the Geneva Accords we had, in fact, signed.
I don’t know; I wasn’t there–but I’d bet good money that when the CIA was enlisting the first Hmong military leaders, promising that they’d help if the war turned against them, they had no idea what more than 200,000 Hmong refugees and immigrants in the United States would mean 50 years later.
Military decisions catalyze migration decisions. We’re terrible at anticipating them ahead of time. But it’d be nice to at least see them acknowledged in hindsight.
Jonas